Bodysong is one of those innovative and intriguing film concepts that sadly
works much better on paper than it does on film. Simon Pummell’s 88 minute
documentary is an original and potentially challenging attempt at exploring
the nature of humanity through close scrutiny of the human body and its
biological journey from birth to death. The film is arranged from a wide
ranging collection of archive footage, some of which stretches back to the
silent era; encompassing everything from newsreel footage of
riots and executions to pornography and laboratory scenes depicting cell
reproduction. Structured into five thematic chapters, the stream of images
are contained and grouped together allowing them to resonate with greater
meaning in association. The visual elements are united with a percussive
soundtrack composed by Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood (his first feature film
score) which goes a long way, in its jarring minimalism, to freshen some of
the more outdated imagery.
Despite arousing initial curiosity, especially after a favourable
opening dealing with the creation of life on it’s tiniest and most
fascinating scale, Bodysong soon inspires little more than tedium through it’s overly
ambitious intent. Pummell opens up the thematic scope of the exercise in an
effort to take in man’s collective fate, this is where the documentary
begins to unravel. In dealing with the human body up close and personal
Bodysong provides an other-worldly insight into our own internal workings.
Here the imagery and the soundtrack merge wonderfully to create an
imaginative and unusual piece of filmmaking. However, as the range of the
film expands the quality of the viewing experience evaporates. Suddenly we
are presented with mundane images of lewd sexual content, peace protesters
clashing with armed forces and other similarly jaded and often-used footage
juxtaposed in such a way that offers very little new. Student’s
being mown down by army tanks in Tienamen Square still maintain the ability
to shock some fifteen years later but their presence here adds little but
increasing incoherence.
The unity of the project as a whole is also undermined, on a technical
front, by the disparate quality of the source materials. Without a
consistent visual style Bodysong falls jarringly flat and a gulf soon
emerges between the soundtrack, the best aspect of the film by far and
fortunately endowed with one author, and the visual track which is bogged down
with far too many. Pummell’s intended plan of reassembling the images to
emphasise specific meaning explodes incoherently in his face and our faces.
Bodysong is an admirable undertaking that falls apart at the seams, mainly
due to a lack of unity brought about by it’s inherent nature: specifically
the re-appropriation of found images. What should be challenging and
evocative eventually becomes little more than an item of vague curiosity.
Reviewer Score: 4/10
Published on Friday, 12 September 2003
Read more from Nik Huggins including:
